Mailgenius guides

Buying Email Lists For Marketing: Why It Is Always A Bad Idea (& How It Impacts Your Deliverability)

Buying email lists for marketing may seem like a tempting shortcut to reach a large number of potential customers quickly. It is always a bad idea and has significant negative consequences for your marketing efforts. This article will explore why buying email lists is not advisable and how it impacts your email deliverability.

Email lists are collections of email addresses used to send marketing messages and promotions to a targeted audience. Buying email lists refers to the practice of purchasing these lists from third-party vendors or sources.

There are several reasons why buying email lists is a bad idea. The quality of contacts on these purchased lists is often poor. You may end up with outdated, inaccurate, or irrelevant email addresses, leading to a low ROI and wasted resources.

Note: Boost your email deliverability now! Test your emails for spam with MailGenius and get actionable feedback to ensure your messages hit the inbox every time. Don’t wait, optimize today. Try a free test today.

Table of Contents

What Are Email Lists?

Email lists are collections of email addresses gathered to send marketing or promotional messages. They can be compiled through sign-ups, registrations, or by purchasing existing databases.

Different Methods for Acquiring an Email List

The method by which you acquire your email list can significantly impact the success of your campaigns. Let’s delve into the various techniques businesses often consider:

Buying Email Lists

Buying email lists refers to the practice of acquiring pre-compiled lists of email addresses from third-party companies. These lists can be obtained by scraping websites or collecting data from online forms.

Renting Email Lists

Instead of buying a list outright, businesses can rent a list from a provider. In this scenario, the provider sends out the email on behalf of the business, and the business never actually sees the email addresses.

Similar to buying lists, rented lists come with their own set of challenges. The recipients haven’t given explicit permission to the renting business, leading to potential legal issues and low engagement rates across all metrics.

A purchased or rented list sends marketing messages to folks who did not agree to receive emails from you.

Owning an Opt-In List

This is the gold standard for email marketing. An opt-in list consists of individuals who have voluntarily provided their email addresses, indicating their interest in receiving communications from the business.

Owning an opt-in list ensures that your email contacts genuinely want to receive marketing emails from you. This leads to higher engagement rates, better deliverability, and a more positive brand image. Strategies like using opt-in forms, leveraging social media, and collecting emails at events and trade shows can help you organically grow your email list.

Is It Bad to Buy Email Lists?

Yes, buying email lists increases the risk of spam complaints. People on these lists have not given their consent to receive emails from you, resulting in high rates of spam complaints, which can harm your sender reputation and deliverability.

Purchasing email lists can have long-term damage to your reputation. Sending unsolicited emails can lead to negative brand associations and a loss of trust among potential customers.

Last but not least, there are legal consequences to buying email lists. In many countries, including the United States and Europe, sending unsolicited emails is prohibited by laws such as the CAN-SPAM Act and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Violating these laws can result in severe penalties and damage to your business’s reputation.

Buying email lists negatively impacts your email deliverability. It leads to increased bounce rates as many of the email addresses on purchased lists may be invalid or inactive. Low open and engagement rates are also common since recipients have not opted in to receive emails from you.

Purchasing email lists often leads to higher unsubscribe and spam complaint rates, further harming your sender reputation and deliverability.

A Deeper Dive Into Why Buying Email Lists a Bad Idea

Using a purchased email list with the assumption that your Email Service Provider (ESP) will ensure message delivery is a misconception. While ESPs work hard to maintain high deliverability, they can’t guarantee successful delivery for purchased lists.

In this section, we’ll uncover why this practice is always a bad idea. From poor quality contacts to the high risk of spam complaints, we’ll explore the damaging effects it can have on your reputation and even legal consequences. Get ready to discover why it’s better to focus on building your own organic and engaged email list for marketing success.

Poor Quality Contacts

Incorporating poor quality contacts into your email list can have significant drawbacks. Let’s explore a few reasons why this is the case:

1. Outdated information: When purchasing email lists, it’s common to encounter outdated or incorrect contact details. As a result, you might find yourself sending emails that bounce or reaching out to inactive, irrelevant contacts, or fake email addresses wasting both time and email marketing efforts.

2. Inaccurate targeting: Buying email lists means relinquishing control over the demographics and interests of your contacts. Consequently, you may send emails to individuals with no interest in your products or services, resulting in low engagement rates.

3. Lack of permission: Contacting individuals from purchased email lists without their explicit permission can lead to higher spam complaints. This can harm your sender reputation and even result in legal consequences if you violate anti-spam laws.

4. No existing relationship or trust: Acquiring email lists means starting with contacts who have no knowledge or relationship with your brand. Establishing trust and cultivating a relationship with these contacts can be challenging and may not yield favorable results.

Instead of purchasing email lists, it’s advisable to build an organic one. This can be done through opt-in forms, lead generation strategies, and engaging with your existing customers. By following best practices for email marketing and maintaining good email hygiene, you can improve the effectiveness of your email campaigns and achieve better results.

High Risk of Spam Complaints

Buying email lists poses a high risk of receiving spam complaints. These lists consist of recipients who have not explicitly given their permission to receive emails from you, increasing the likelihood of them reporting your emails as spam. Such complaints can have a negative impact on your email sender reputation and may result in your messages being blocked or filtered by email service providers. A significant number of spam complaints signals poor quality of the email list and can even lead to legal consequences. Therefore, it is crucial to prioritize obtaining permission-based email lists in order to ensure optimal deliverability rates and maintain a reputable and trustworthy brand image.

Damage to Reputation

Buying email lists can have severe consequences for businesses, including damage to reputation. Companies risk association with spamming and unethical marketing practices, which can lead to negative feedback and a decline in customer trust. This perception of being untrustworthy or disrespectful of privacy can have a detrimental impact on businesses’ reputation.

Purchasing email lists often results in high bounce rates and spam complaints, further damaging the sender’s reputation and reducing the chances of reaching recipients’ inboxes in future campaigns. This negatively impacts a company’s ability to communicate effectively with its intended audience.

Utilizing bought email lists can have legal consequences. Violations of data protection laws may lead to fines or legal actions, which not only cause financial setbacks but also harm the company’s reputation. It is essential for businesses to prioritize ethical and permission-based email marketing strategies to avoid such legal and reputational damage.

To prevent damage to their reputation, businesses should focus on alternative email marketing methods. Instead of buying email lists, they should endeavor to build an organic email list through opt-in forms and lead generation. This allows for targeted and engaged recipients who willingly provide their contact information. Engaging with existing customers also helps strengthen relationships and maintain a positive reputation.

Legal Consequences

Buying email lists can have serious legal consequences.

1. Violation of privacy laws: Purchasing email lists often violates privacy laws, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union. This can result in significant legal penalties.

2. Spamming regulations: Sending unsolicited emails to individuals without their explicit consent is considered spamming. Most countries have laws and regulations to protect individuals from this practice. By purchasing email lists, businesses risk violating these regulations and facing legal consequences.

3. Damage to reputation: Using purchased email lists can damage a company’s reputation. Recipients may view the sender as untrustworthy or unethical when they receive unsolicited emails. This can lead to negative associations with the brand and potential loss of customers.

4. Lawsuits and fines: If individuals on a purchased email list file complaints or take legal action, businesses can face lawsuits and hefty fines. This can also create negative publicity and further damage the company’s reputation.

It is best to focus on building an organic email list through permission-based marketing methods. By obtaining consent from genuinely interested individuals, businesses can comply with privacy laws and maintain a positive reputation.

How Does Buying Email Lists Impact Deliverability?

Buying email lists can negatively hurt the deliverability of an email marketing campaign. Reputable email marketing services need to keep a high deliverability rate to maintain their reputation. Let’s dive into the consequences that arise from this questionable marketing practice. We’ll uncover the truth behind increased bounce rates, low open and engagement rates, as well as higher unsubscribe and spam complaint rates. Brace yourselves for some eye-opening insights into the repercussions of purchasing email lists for your marketing campaigns.

Increased Bounce Rates

Increased bounce rates occur when purchasing email lists for marketing. Contacts on these lists may not be genuinely interested in your products or services, resulting in emails that are not successfully delivered. This happens because email addresses on bought lists may be outdated or invalid, causing emails to bounce. Contacts who did not voluntarily sign up are less likely to engage, causing more bounces. Sending to a large number of unengaged contacts from a purchased list can trigger email spam filters, further increasing bounce rates.

High bounce rates have negative effects on email marketing. They can damage your sender reputation and deliverability as ISPs monitor bounce rates. If a pattern of high bounces is detected, your emails may be classified as spam, leading to blocking or placement in recipients’ spam folders.

To avoid increased bounce rates, it is recommended to build an organic email list through permission-based marketing practices. Obtain consent from individuals who willingly choose to receive emails from your company. With engaged contacts, you can improve deliverability and overall email marketing success.

Low Open and Engagement Rates

Low open and engagement rates indicate that many recipients do not open or engage with your emails. This can harm your email marketing efforts by reducing campaign effectiveness and limiting message reach. Factors such as unappealing subject lines, irrelevant content, or poor timing of email delivery can cause low open rates. Engagement rates, including click-through rates and conversions, show the level of interest and interaction from recipients. Low engagement rates suggest that your emails do not capture attention or motivate action. Consequences of low open and engagement rates include wasted time and resources and a negative impact on sender reputation. ISPs may interpret low engagement rates as a sign that recipients do not value your emails and may prioritize them lower in inboxes.

Higher Unsubscribe and Spam Complaint Rates

Higher Unsubscribe and Spam Complaint Rates often result from buying email lists. Purchased lists often contain outdated or incorrect email addresses, leading to more unsubscribe requests. Recipients may not recognize the sender or have no interest in receiving unsolicited emails, resulting in increased opt-outs. The lack of permission-based marketing leads to these consequences.

Contacts on bought lists are also more likely to mark emails as spam since they did not willingly provide their information. This can greatly damage sender reputation and reduce deliverability rates.

Sending emails without consent violates anti-spam laws, which can have legal consequences and harm a company’s reputation.

Engaging with existing customers, using opt-in forms, and employing lead-generation tactics are effective alternatives to purchasing lists.

Regularly cleaning the email list is recommended to improve email engagement and minimize unsubscribe and spam complaints. Remove inactive subscribers and promptly process opt-outs to maintain a healthy and engaged email audience.

Alternatives to Buying Email Lists

Looking for better ways to expand your email list? Let’s explore some alternatives to buying email lists. We’ll cover various effective strategies to attract and engage potential subscribers, from building an organic email list to utilizing opt-in forms and lead generation techniques. We’ll discuss the importance of engaging with existing customers and how it can lead to increased conversions. Say goodbye to ineffective and potentially harmful practices, and hello to smart, sustainable email list growth.

Building an Organic Email List

Building an organic email list is crucial for successful email marketing campaigns. Follow these steps to naturally grow your email list organically:

Create valuable content: Offer free resources, exclusive discounts, or informative newsletters to incentivize website visitors to sign up for your organic email list.
Optimize website opt-in forms: Strategically place an opt-in or sign-up form on your website, including the homepage, blog posts, and landing pages. You can offer a lead magnet on a landing page to entice your visitors to subscribe. Make it as easy and convenient to subscribe to your email list.
Utilize social media: Promote the benefits of subscribing to your email list on various social media platforms. Encourage your followers to join and be part of your growing email community.
Guest blogging: Share your expertise by writing guest blog posts for industry publications. Include a link to your website’s opt-in form in your author bio, attracting targeted traffic and increasing email sign-ups for your organic email list.
Host webinars or events: Engage with your target audience and offer valuable insights by hosting webinars or events related to your industry. Require interested attendees to provide their email addresses for registration to expand your organic email list.
Run contests or giveaways: Spark interest and capture potential subscribers by running contests or giveaways. Make joining and subscribing to your email list a requirement for participation.

With these strategies, you can effectively build and grow an organic email list, reaching and connecting with a valuable audience.