Mailgenius guides

How to Get Blacklisted: Unveiling the Pitfalls to Steer Clear of in Email Marketing

Your email list is your goldmine, a direct line to both potential customers and loyal followers. But what happens when that goldmine turns into a field of landmines, with every email sent risking detonation in the form of blacklisting? The consequences can be dire: severed connections, lost opportunities, and a tarnished reputation that takes years to rebuild.

From the subtle missteps to glaring errors, we dissect the various factors that can land you on the dreaded blacklist and, more importantly, how to claw your way back from it. Whether you’re a seasoned marketer or just starting out, understanding the dynamics of email blacklisting is your first line of defense in safeguarding your digital assets and fostering fruitful connections in the online space.

Note: Don’t let your emails fall into the dreaded spam folder! Take control of your email marketing campaigns with MailGenius. We are offering you the opportunity to try MailGenius, test your inbox placement, and receive 3 FREE tests to evaluate your email deliverability.

Why Do People Get Blacklisted?

One of the primary reasons people find themselves on an email blacklist is due to sending emails to recipients who haven’t willingly subscribed to their program. This includes utilizing scraped or purchased contact lists, which is frowned upon in the industry and considered a spammy behavior. It’s essential to only email contacts who have willingly subscribed to your program to maintain a healthy sender reputation.

Understanding the criteria that lead to an IP getting blacklisted can be instrumental. To check if your IP is blacklisted, conduct an IP blacklist check or visit the blacklist’s website to search for your IP address. While most blacklist databases usually offer general reasons for listings, they typically do not disclose the specific email addresses associated with blacklisted IPs.

Here, we delve into the various factors that can cause blacklisted IP addresses and the repercussions of landing on a blacklist operators.

Technical Listings: Configuration Issues

Technical listings are a common cause of IP blacklisting, often stemming from mail server configuration issues. These blacklist issues online can range from missing or incorrect reverse DNS records to improper banner greetings and mail servers operating within a suspicious range of IP addresses. Ensuring that your mail server configurations are correctly set up can prevent technical listings and help maintain a positive sender reputation.

Policy Listings: Non-Compliance with Receiving Server Policies

Policy listings occur when the receiving server chooses not to accept emails from certain countries or ISPs, particularly those with a history of not adequately handling “unsubscribe” requests. This form of blacklisting is a precautionary measure to protect users from potential spam and unsolicited emails originating from regions or ISPs with a notorious reputation. Adhering to global email marketing standards and respecting unsubscribe requests can mitigate the risk of policy listings.

Evidence-Based Listings: Involvement in Unsolicited Emails

Evidence-based listings are perhaps the most direct form of blacklisting, where the server has received tangible evidence, either direct or indirect, of the sending IP address engaging in the distribution of unsolicited emails. This form of blacklisting is a reaction to proven spam activities, and avoiding engagement in spam-related activities is crucial to prevent evidence-based listings.

High Spam Complaints

Receiving high email spam complaints is a red flag that can swiftly lead to blacklisting. Spam complaints occur when recipients mark your emails as spam, indicating dissatisfaction with the content they are receiving. This section explores the reasons behind high spam complaints and how to mitigate them to avoid blacklisting.

Spam complaints are taken seriously by Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and an email service provider. When the number of complaints crosses a certain threshold, it can significantly tarnish your sender reputation, leading to potential blacklisting. It’s vital to monitor spam complaints closely and take proactive measures to reduce them, thereby safeguarding your email marketing campaigns from being derailed.

One of the primary reasons behind high spam complaints is the lack of relevance in the content being sent to subscribers. Sending content that does not resonate with the audience’s preferences or needs can lead to dissatisfaction and increased spam complaints. Crafting content that is tailored to your audience’s interests and providing value can significantly reduce the likelihood of your emails being marked as spam.

Engaging in permission-based email marketing is a crucial strategy to avoid high spam complaints. This involves obtaining explicit consent from individuals before adding them to your email list. Implementing a double opt-in system, where subscribers confirm their subscription, can ensure that you are building a list of individuals who are genuinely interested in your content, thereby reducing the risk of spam complaints.

Bad Lists Or Addresses

the presence of bad lists or addresses can be a significant hindrance, often signaling to Internet Service Providers (ISPs) that your list may not be opted-in or current. This section explores the repercussions of harboring bad lists or addresses and the mechanisms that blacklists employ to identify spammers.

A high incidence of bounced email addresses can be a red flag to ISPs, indicating that your email list may not be up-to-date or consists of non-opted-in contacts. This not only tarnishes your sender reputation but can also lead to your IP being blacklisted. It is essential to regularly clean your email list, removing inactive or invalid addresses to prevent bounces and maintain a healthy sender reputation.

The Trap of Spamtrap Addresses

Blacklists often employ spamtrap addresses as a tactic to identify and catch spammers. A spamtrap is an email address that is not used by any individual but can still be found publicly and harvested for lists. These addresses are traps set to catch spammers, as any email sent to these addresses is a clear indication of non-opted-in lists, often found on very old or purchased lists. Falling into the spamtrap can lead to severe consequences, including blacklisting. Read our guide to locate spamtrap email addresses.

The Perils of Purchased Lists

Utilizing purchased lists is a dangerous practice that can quickly lead to blacklisting. These lists often contain a plethora of spamtrap addresses and inactive contacts, making you an easy target for blacklists. It is highly recommended to build your email list organically, ensuring that your contacts have willingly opted-in to receive your content, thereby avoiding the pitfalls associated with purchased lists.

A Surge In List Size

A well-maintained email marketing list is expected to grow gradually over time, reflecting a steady increase in customer or lead engagement. This growth is generally a result of individuals signing up willingly to receive emails, indicating a genuine interest in your content or services. However, a sudden and substantial surge in the size of an email list can raise red flags with most ISPs and email service providers. This abrupt increase often signals the possibility that a list has been purchased, which is a practice frowned upon in the industry due to the potential inclusion of non-opted-in contacts, which can lead to a higher risk of landing on a blacklist.

In this context, it is crucial for marketers to be cautious about how they expand their email lists. A sudden influx of new addresses can trigger spam filters, leading to increased scrutiny and potential blacklisting. To avoid this, it is recommended to grow your list organically, encouraging individuals to sign up through legitimate channels such as your website or social media platforms. Moreover, implementing a double opt-in system can further ensure that the growth of your list is genuine and compliant with best practices, fostering a positive relationship with both ISPs and your audience, and enhancing the overall effectiveness of your email marketing campaigns.

Spam-Related Activities

Engaging in activities that are considered spammy is a surefire way to end up on an email blacklist. This includes sending emails with fraudulent content, malware, phishing attempts, and other suspicious behaviors. ISPs like Gmail, Yahoo, and Outlook employ spam filters to sieve out such content, and landing on their blacklists can severely restrict your access to potential and existing customers.

To combat the menace of spam, the Domain Name System-based Blackhole List (DNSBL) plays a pivotal role. This real-time blacklist databases or IP addresses or domain names associated with spam or suspicious content emanating from low-trust senders. Major email servers like Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo maintain their own running blacklists, ready to add suspicious senders at any moment. Being listed on these blacklists can result in a significant loss of access to potential leads and returning customers, especially if listed on a popular email service provider’s blacklist.

For high-volume senders, requesting a dedicated IP address from your ESP or SMTP relay service can prevent your deliverability from being influenced by others, allowing you to establish your own sender reputation.

The Consequences of Landing on Prominent Blacklists

Being listed on prominent blacklists can have severe repercussions for businesses. Some of the most notable blacklists include the Spamhaus Block List, XBL Exploits Block List, and SenderScore, each varying in terms of the difficulty of removal. Landing on these lists can not only hamper your email marketing campaigns but also cut off access to new leads and even loyal, long-time customers. Depending on the specific blacklist, it could potentially cost a significant percentage of your regular revenue.

Proactive Measures to Avoid Spam-Related Blacklisting

To avoid finding yourself on an email blacklist, it’s imperative to adhere to best practices in email marketing. This includes creating high-quality, engaging content that adds value to the recipient, maintaining an up-to-date contact list, and avoiding the use of spam words in your emails. Additionally, obtaining consent before sending emails and implementing a double opt-in system can further safeguard against blacklisting. It’s also advisable to refrain from purchasing email lists, as they can often contain spam traps that lead to blacklisting.

Steering clear of spam-related activities is not only a matter of maintaining a good sender reputation but also a crucial step in ensuring the success and effectiveness of your email marketing campaigns.

How To Remove Your IP Address From A Blacklist

Finding your IP address on a blacklist can be a distressing experience, significantly hindering your email marketing efforts. However, it’s not the end of the road; there are actionable steps you can take to remove your IP from a blacklist and restore your sender reputation. Firstly, it’s essential to identify the reason behind the blacklisting, which could range from sending emails to spamtrap addresses to a surge in list size. Once identified, rectify the issues promptly, whether it’s improving the quality of your content or implementing a double opt-in system to ensure a more engaged audience. Additionally, consider reaching out to the blacklist operator with a well-crafted delisting request, showcasing the improvements you’ve made to comply with best practices.

Fortunately, many blacklist operators offer a self-service removal feature, a tool that empowers marketers to take charge of their sender reputation by facilitating the removal process themselves. This feature is designed to assist users in rectifying the issues that led to the blacklisting, thereby reinstating their standing in the email community.